Coventry City's 5-4 League Cup victory against Nottingham Forest came 31st in a vote carried out by the Football League for the Best Ever League Cup Moment Top 50.
Dennis Tueart's goal against Newcastle United in the 1976 Final was picked as the defining moment with Paul Robinson's heroics for Leeds against Swindon in 2003 was in second place with York City beating Manchester United 3-0 at Old Trafford in third.
Speaking about his goal, Dennis Tueart said: Tueart said: "For my goal to be voted for by the people of the game, the supporters, as the number one League Cup Moment makes me feel very proud.
"I'm of the opinion that emotion, passion and pride is what makes football special. Football supporters are unique. They make the game what it is."
City Coach Frankie Bunn's six goals for Oldham saw him finish in 13th place.